Are We Buying Coffee Makers for the Coffee or the Features?

Disclosure: We may earn a commission when you purchase through links on our site. This does not influence our reviews or recommendations.

Miranda’s coffee station 11/14/2026

I have a habit of spending far too much time researching appliances before buying them. I'll compare specifications, read reviews, dig through Reddit threads, and investigate every possible reason I might regret a purchase. So, after all that research, you'd probably expect me to have some elaborate coffee machine sitting on my kitchen counter.

Instead, one of my favorite coffee makers is a black Nespresso Essenza Mini with two buttons. Meanwhile, there are coffee machines offering everything from built-in grinders and automatic milk frothing to touchscreens, Wi-Fi connectivity, and more drink settings than I'd know what to do with.

I love a good piece of technology, and I'm willing to pay for features that improve my experience. But more features don't automatically mean better coffee. How many of those extras actually make a meaningful difference, and how many are just something new and shiny to help justify a higher price tag?

More features don't always mean better coffee

I'm skeptical of coffee makers that promise to do everything. I'd rather have a machine that does one thing exceptionally well than one that tries to do ten different things and delivers mediocre results across the board. Take those multifunction coffee makers that accommodate different capsule formats, brew regular coffee, and prepare espresso-style drinks.

It's a neat concept, but I'm not going to assume a machine makes great coffee just because it accepts five different types of pods. Versatility needs to prove itself.

I’m also wary of unnecessary complexity. Every additional component is another thing that can go wrong. A built-in milk frother sounds nice, but it’s also another system to clean and maintain. Add a grinder, touchscreen, and several automated functions, and suddenly there’s a lot more to keep up with. If those extras aren’t making the coffee better or the process easier, what exactly am I paying for? I don’t need a coffee maker that impresses me with everything it can do. I need one that impresses me with how well it does it.

Why I chose the Nespresso Essenza Mini

My decision to buy the Essenza Mini wasn't just about simplicity. I had some specific requirements, and finding a machine that met them took a fair amount of research.

For starters, I wanted espresso-style coffee rather than another regular drip coffee maker. I deal with acid reflux, and I've found that large servings of regular coffee don't always agree with me. Espresso-based drinks tend to work better because I can start with a small, concentrated shot and add plenty of milk without losing that strong coffee flavor. That's just what works for me. At the time, I'd also been visiting my favorite coffee shop more frequently than I like to admit, because I loved its iced espresso drinks. Buying a machine that could make something similar at home seemed like a better use of my money.

I considered Keurig, but I wasn't looking for another way to brew regular coffee. I wanted concentrated espresso-style shots for lattes, which pointed me toward Nespresso. And yes, before the coffee purists come for me, I know Nespresso isn't quite the same as espresso from a traditional machine. But for the milk-heavy drinks I typically make, it's close enough for me.

Then came the decision between Original and Vertuo. The Original Line appealed to me because it uses pressure-based extraction and focuses on espresso and lungo servings, while Vertuo uses centrifugal extraction and offers a broader range of drink sizes. More importantly for my budget, Original machines have far more third-party compatible capsule options, giving me the freedom to shop around instead of relying on a small selection of brands.

I eventually settled on the Breville version of the Essenza Mini because it had the straightforward design and established reputation I was looking for. Two programmable buttons, a compact footprint, and no elaborate menu system to navigate. It's not an exciting machine to describe, but that's okay. I bought it to make good coffee, not to entertain me while it does it.

Buy the Nespresso Essenza Mini on Amazon!

I'd rather read the complaints before buying

I'm not typically the first person lining up to buy the newest coffee machine. I prefer products that have been around long enough to establish a reputation, with feedback from people who've actually used them. And when I'm researching a purchase, I tend to spend more time reading the negative reviews than the positive ones. A glowing five-star review might tell me the coffee tastes great, but I want to know what happens after six months, a year, or even longer. Does the machine start leaking? Is cleaning it more trouble than making the coffee? Are there any recurring complaints?

I don't automatically believe every one-star review, either. Some people have unreasonable expectations, and the occasional defective unit doesn't necessarily mean an entire product line is unreliable. That's why I look across multiple websites and forums rather than relying on one retailer's reviews.

With the Essenza Mini, for example, I went into the purchase expecting some noise while brewing. Sure enough, it's noticeably loud when pushing water through a capsule. But that only lasts a few seconds, and I've never found it particularly bothersome. Knowing about a drawback beforehand makes it much easier to decide whether I can live with it. In this case, a few seconds of noise was hardly a dealbreaker.

Paying more per cup doesn't always mean spending more

Even when I'm drinking coffee regularly, I typically only make one a day, using one or occasionally two capsules for a larger iced latte. I also go through periods when I can't drink coffee at all, sometimes for a month or two. That made buying expensive bags of beans frustrating. I'd open a bag, use a portion of it, and then stop drinking coffee long enough for the rest to lose much of its freshness.

Individually sealed capsules made more sense. They last longer, and the Original Line lets me shop around for affordable third-party pods or stock up on Nespresso capsules during sales. Making my own iced lattes also costs considerably less than buying them from a coffee shop.

It's the same way I look at features. A lower price doesn't mean much if I'm paying for something I won't use, whether that's a bag of coffee or a function on a machine.

Sometimes I want the ritual, not the button

Sometimes, making coffee is half the fun. That's when I reach for my pour-over setup, complete with a burr grinder and an electric gooseneck kettle. It's more work than pressing a button, but I enjoy the process of grinding fresh beans, slowly pouring the water, and smelling the coffee as it brews. Plus, it's nice having the option to make a regular cup of coffee when friends or family come over.

Now, you might wonder why someone questioning feature-heavy coffee makers owns multiple pieces of equipment just to brew a cup of coffee. Fair question. But each piece serves a specific purpose. My grinder produces a consistent grind, while the kettle gives me control over the water temperature and how I pour it. They're features I actually use, and I can choose each piece of equipment based on how well it does its job.

A machine with a built-in grinder, milk frother, and touchscreen might offer all sorts of conveniences, but I'd want to know how well those individual features perform before paying for the whole package. With my pour-over setup, I know exactly what I'm paying for.

Do I need two different ways to make coffee? No. But sometimes I want to enjoy the whole process, and other times I just want an iced latte without having to think about grind sizes, water temperatures, or extraction. I have two methods that each do what I want them to do, without asking either to be something else.

Buy the COSORI Gooseneck Kettle on Amazon!

What would actually make me replace my coffee maker?

A proper espresso machine with a built-in grinder and automatic milk frothing is something I'd be interested in testing. I'd want to know whether the improvement in coffee quality would be enough to convince me to make the switch. But it would take more than an impressive specifications sheet. Does the coffee actually taste better? Is the machine reliable? Do those extra features make preparing a drink easier or more enjoyable?

Those are the things that would convince me to upgrade, not just the fact that a newer machine can do more. After all the hours I spent comparing coffee makers, I ended up choosing one with two buttons. Nearly two years later, I still haven't wished it did more.

Miranda Richter

Miranda Richter is the News Editor at Ultimate Technology Reviews, covering new product announcements, technology launches, buying guides, reviews, and other developments across the consumer technology industry. With more than a decade of professional cosmetology experience and an active Florida cosmetology license, she also brings firsthand expertise to UTR's coverage of beauty technology, hair tools, personal care products, and related tech.

Next
Next

Introducing the UTR Ultimate Awards: Recognizing Excellence, Innovation, and Outstanding Value in Technology